According to a report in one of the local rags – which has subsequently been picked up by at least one of the nationals – an 83 year-old woman has been removed from the patient list at the doctors’ practice where she has been registered for 30 years.
So far, so completely uninteresting.
Why then the interest? The following extract from the letter the surgery sent to inform her of her delisting should explain:
“Our greatest concern is for your health and convenience but also taking into consideration green travelling issues. Re: Carbon footprints and winter weather conditions, we feel it would be advisable for patients to register at surgeries nearer to where they live.
“We would be very grateful if you could make the necessary arrangements to re-register at another practice.”
At its heart this appears to an issue of someone living outside of the catchment area of their GP – and in the case of Mrs Mulachy some checking reveals that she lives within SS1 and the surgery will only take patients from within SS0. What is not clear is whether or not she has recently moved across the postcode boundary. If she has then the removal is certainly permissible under British Medical Association (BMA) guidelines
[…]there are also cases where the practice requests removal because they have become aware that the patient has moved to an address which is outside their practice area. This is necessary because otherwise the practice may still be under an obligation to visit the patient when medically necessary at a location outside their practice area. In such cases, patients are given a thirty-day time limit to make alternative arrangements before removal by the PCO.
even if the action appears somewhat cruel.
If however she is still in the property she lived in when she registered with the practice some 30 years ago then their decision would seem to be lacking in common sense given that they have had plenty of time to do so before now.
A bit of a non-story then – or at least it would have been if it wasn’t for the weasel words that the surgery used:
Our greatest concern is for your health and convenience but also taking into consideration green travelling issues. Re: Carbon footprints and winter weather conditions…
That’s right, they have couched their “suggestion” in terms of the religion of climate change. Since Mrs Mulachy is housebound one assumes that it is their carbon footprint and their ability to get to her when there is snow on the ground which they are worried about, not hers.
Does anyone know what the carbon footprint of a piece of German automative engineering is over the course of a mile? Is it substantially more than it would be over the course of, say, half a mile? Do all the GPs and other staff members live close to the surgery in order to minimise the carbon footprints they generate just travelling to work? More importantly, when did carbon footprints become something for a doctors’ surgery to worry about?
Their concern about the small amounts of snow we have had around here in the last few years also seems very much misplaced. Yes, trips take longer as people become more cautious but she is not living somewhere that would be impossible to get to.
Could it be then that the sudden discovery that she is not in the catchment area is simply the result of her making a complaint? The BMA guidelines say that complaints are not a reason to ditch patients but her address would certainly appear to provide this surgery with an easy loophole to exploit.