Whilst plugging his latest book at the Cheltenham Literature Festival last Saturday, professional plant-bother Monty Don said that he would
[…] like to see a garden or an allotment compulsory, so if it’s a flat, it comes with an allotment, and if it’s a house, it has to have a garden.
To which the only rational response is language that my mother would still scold me for.
Part of the reason I live in a flat is that I do not want the hassle of a garden; indeed I am so uninterested in anything plant related that I have nary a single one in my flat. If I did own a house with a garden area the most adventurous I’d get with it is a patch of grass to be mown every so often and lots of paving. I can’t tell a weed from another piece of plant life and have no desire to kneel in the dirt pulling one out of the ground.
If other people want an allotment, wish to turn their garden space into something that Tom and Barbara Good would feel at home in or feel the need to attempt to create something that would win the Chelsea Flower Show then bully for them. Just don’t inflict them on those of us who don’t want them.
Oh, but Monty has plans for people like you too! You can loan your space to someone else (and if everyone else has a compulsory garden, who?) to use. Because everyone wants to share their living space with a stranger, right?
To elaborate on Julia’s brilliant idea, you could always rent your garden to that nice bearded man who walks 5 paces in front of his wife who is dressed like a black post box. You can even give him permission to have a little shed where he can store those bags of fertiliser, sugar, and clock parts. Then when he invites his friends round for a barbecue, you will have a wonderful view of the very humane way they slit the throat of the goat while singing their delightful little song. No harm in that, surely. However, do not join them with a tray of bacon sandwiches. On the other hand, though………………….!
Of course gardens should in no way be compulsory but in a round-about way he sort of has a point. Current planning laws actively promote the building of high-density housing with no surrounding space (and also insufficient parking, which does not result in reduced car use but DOES cause congested, dangerous streets). OK, some people want to live in such high-density developments but many do not. The problem lies in the fact that the market has been distorted by the prevalence of such developments resulting in properties incorporating a drive and/or garden becoming prohibitively expensive. As such, people who DO want a bit of space often cannot afford it.
Is such space a “luxury”? Some might say so, however there are many people for whom high-density living is a psychologically negative experience. We are all different in both our psychologies and our physical needs. Bringing some rationality and common sense back into the planning laws would be a step towards providing people with housing to meet their personal requirements (and by this I mean more flexibility, not greater compulsion). In my mind the planning laws should favour provision of gardens but not compel it.
I certainly won’t argue against the proposition that the planning system is comprehensively borked with the result that we have inflated home prices due to difficulties in getting permission to build new properties and that many of those properties, especially houses in urban areas, are small – lacking in both garden and parking space.
If people want a garden then I have no problems with that. What I do not want is one (or, worse, an allotment) foisted on me by some fascist who wants us all to to support his particular hobby.