On the difficulty of buying booze

Hello, my name is MG. I’m 33 years old and I need to tell you that sometimes I like to buy alcohol from my local Tesco supermarket.

In a country populated by grown-ups that had a government with a relaxed attitude to the drinking habits of the citizenry such a confession would obviously be unnecessary.

However as we all know the UK has none of these things which is why I find myself confronted, with increasing regularity, with demands from the checkout assistants that I produce ID to confirm that I am indeed old enough to purchase the wine or beer that sometimes falls into my shopping basket.

You would have thought that it should be fairly easy to realise that I am clearly an adult, even if you are unable to say exactly how far beyond the currently minimum legal age of 18 I am. Sadly this is not the case as my local store operates a policy of asking for ID if you don’t look over 25.

Yes, the first time I was asked I was flattered. However as I do not habitually carry ID with me – UK law not yet requiring me to do so – this quickly turned into irritation and these days I save time by just going straight to irritated.

On the first few times I argued but you quickly learn that arguing with a checkout assistant is like arguing with a brick wall (and their supervisors are no better) so I no longer bother and instead start unpacking any goods I have already placed into my bags back to the checkout before picking up my (now empty) bags and walking out of the store.

This inane idea of challenging anyone who might be under 25 is the follow up to the ‘Challenge 21’ policy and is the brainchild of the Retail of Alcohol Standards Group (RASG) and it is co-ordinated by the Wine and Spirit Trade Association (WSTA).

It’s purpose? To reduce the amount of alcohol sold to under 18s. It’s members? Most, if not every, supermarket chain operating in the UK.

Why does it exist? Because following a meeting with Charles Clarke, one of the many authoritarian Home Secretaries this country had to put up with under the last government, the retailers apparently mutually agreed to sell out and get into bed with government, rather than to stand up to them and live with the bullying that would have probably otherwise have followed. Thus ‘Challenge 21’ was born.

However as those blessed with half a brain cell and an understanding of history know, surrendering just means you get to spend a good long while being someone else’s bitch. In the case of the RASG this means that their work is supported by the Home Office, the Department of Culture, Media and Sport and the Department of Health.

This is apparently evidenced by the newer ‘Challenge 25‘ scheme:

However, with levels of sales to minors still not low enough and the personal consequences of illegal sales for the member of shop staff more severe, retailer employees requested a program which gives them a greater backing and a higher margin of error in challenging customers for proof of age.

Yes, when it is your paycheque on the line, you want to do your damnedest to ensure that you don’t get screwed over. Sadly it also means that common sense tends to go out of the window at the same time.

However how much did the RASG fight when the government of the day looked to start imposed these harsher penalties – or did their previous lack of doing so mean that they had no corner to fight?

I think it is probably safe to say that it was the government which decided that the level of alcohol sales to minors was still too high, although what that figure is I do not know – but one suspects that any figure above zero would be considered too high. Given that the utter elimination of alcohol sales to children is impossible, will the industry wake up to the situation they have found themselves in or are they now, like CAMRA, completely suffering from Stockholm Syndrome?

I meanwhile have decided that the time has come to find another supermarket to spend my money in.

8 thoughts on “On the difficulty of buying booze”

  1. You may find that switching supermarkets doesn’t help. My Mrs is 31 and she is often being challenged for ID for booze and fags. We started with the “We won’t shop here again then”, but eventually ran out of places to go.

    • I shall try and see. My other option is always the local off-licence. I think there we still have one of them in the area.

  2. I was discussing the issue of rules and our cultural approach to them with my parish priest yesterday. In that discussion we were looking at the relationship between virtue and compliance with both civil and canon laws, but the same thing tends to apply to compliance and judgement. As a society, we think “so long as I comply with the rules, I’m OK” and “I must comply with this rule, even though my judgement shows compliance in this case to be worthless”. An example in point: if at 2am you come to a road junction, there is no traffic in any direction, but the light facing you is red then in this country we always stop; in other, Southern European, countries this is not the case-the driver will make the judgement that it is safe to cross the junciton and will do so.

    And, of course, in towns and cities we use rules to separate traffic and pedestrians. We put traffic calming onto residential roads precisely *because* the rules have made the roads unsafe for mixed use: drivers go in the roadway, pedestrians go on the pavements. And this results in a lack of engagement between road users which imperils pedestrians and cyclists, simply because the car driver thinks “I’m OK, I’m obeying the rules which apply to me”.

    Alas, when bad things happen, the first line of investigation is always whether the rules were being obeyed. The penalties for not following rules are harsh, whereas there are often none for using bad judgement.

    • Nail. Head.

      The ability to use one’s discretion in this country has been legislated out of existence thanks to the mantra of ‘something must be done’ and ‘someone must be at fault’.

      What I’m not sure is whether there is still time to correct this problem or if we have already passed the point of no return.

  3. I saw a guy with a beard showing his passport to buy a bottle of wine, and I thought ‘ffs, this is getting ridiculous’. I expect I’m past the point of getting challenged, but I applaud anyone who says ‘you know what, keep the shopping’ and walks out.

    Back in the good old days (the 80s in my case), you could buy alcohol if you were 16, as a boy, and less if you were a girl, and the pubs didn’t mind if you didn’t draw attention to yourself. Not all pubs, of course.

    Sadly, I expect the youngsters are now fully trained. As I’ve remarked before, young people are having their childhood extended ever more, and seem to me a strange mix of worldly knowledge and utter naivity.

  4. A couple of years ago, my 45-year old self was buying some wine in Morrisons. The checkout chick (about 17) asked me for ID. Genuinely confused I asked why I needed to identify myself? She said to prove I was over 18.

    So I asked her out on a date.

    With a look of horror/confusion she declined. “But why?”

    “You’re much too old for me”

    “Yes, I am indeed much to old for you, now sell me the fucking booze”

    ——————————————————————————

    In an unrelated incident, Mrs SAOT was buying wine and was ID checked, she pointed to our two year old son but then realised the utter futility of imagining you would have to be over 18 to have a two year old these days.

Comments are closed.