Free the Pontypridd One

According to news reports, a 21 year old man from Pontypridd is being held at Swansea police station following offensive remarks made on Twitter after Fabrice Muamba collapsed on the pitch yesterday afternoon.

Whilst I in no way condone what the young man said, I find it despicable that he has been arrested for it.

To quote Voltaire Evelyn Beatrice Hall*:

I do not agree with what you have to say, but I’ll defend to the death your right to say it.

R.I.P. Free Speech

Update: Quote attribution changed. Thank you to @WelshToy for point this out.

* It appears I may have been wrong all these years. According to Wikipedia:

In Evelyn Beatrice Hall’s biography of Voltaire, she coined the following phrase to illustrate Voltaire’s beliefs: “I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.”

Alcohol gimmickry

According to a report on the BBC yesterday, the government is planning to implement so-called ‘Sobriety Orders’:

Offenders who commit alcohol-fuelled crimes are to be monitored with ankle tags and breath-tested to ensure they stop drinking, under government plans.

Police will have powers to impose “sobriety orders” on drinkers cautioned for minor offences, such as criminal damage or public disorder.

There will be regular breath tests, with known weekend bingers tested then, and ankle tags to monitor movements.

Sure, we can all agree that people who commit crimes, be they under the influence or not need to be punished but is breath testing potential drunks (at what cost in police time?) really a good idea?

Given what we know about how much profit government makes from alcohol I think not.

For serious and violent criminals with drink problems, ministers want to introduce new laws enabling the courts to impose sobriety orders as part of a suspended or community sentence.

If they are serious and/or violent criminals then they shouldn’t be getting suspended or community sentences in the first place – they should be sent to gaol!

Offenders would have to wear ankle tags that continuously monitored alcohol levels, for up to four months.

Erm, how does an ankle tag measure the amount of blood in one’s alcohol stream? Are those wearing one supposed to breathe on it every so often or is it going to be taking a blood sample on a regular basis?

Another type of tag, which has been tried out in England, uses a GPS system which would alert the authorities when people visited certain proscribed areas – such as pubs.

Ok, standard GPS tracking. Civilian or Military accuracy however? Don’t want to have issues with someone being in – or claiming they were in – the building next door. Also, it is possible to go to a pub and not drink.

Justice Minister Nick Herbert said: “Alcohol-fuelled violence and criminality causes mayhem in our towns and city centres.”

Mayhem? The dictionary defines mayhem as:

  1. Violent or damaging disorder; chaos.
  2. The crime of maliciously injuring or maiming someone, originally so as to render the victim defenceless.

Which is a somewhat OTT description of the civil disorder that a minority of people get up to after a few sherbets.

Indeed this idea seems so flawed that even the politicians on the opposition benches as well as the rent seekers can spot the holes:

Shadow justice secretary Sadiq Khan said: “Increased use of community sentences, tagging, monitoring and initiatives to support those with drug and alcohol dependencies will require more resources.

“The government need to answer important questions about how they propose to fund increased use of community sentences given the Ministry of Justice budget faces cuts of a quarter.

The Prison Reform Trust said the government seemed to be resorting to “populist gimmicks” when current policies were actually working and had public support.

If this silly idea does go ahead, how long before someone suggests that each and everyone of us who likes a drink needs to have our consumption monitored, regardless of whether or not we have done something criminal under the influence of alcohol?

Smacking

David Lammy, the MP for Tottenham, has aroused the ire of many by suggesting that one of the reasons behind last summer’s riots is that parents are afraid to smack their children.

In an interview with LBC Radio to publicise his book (Out Of The Ashes: After The Riots) Lammy said:

“Many of my constituents came up to me after the riots and blamed the Labour Government, saying: ‘You guys stopped us being able to smack our children’.

“I have to say when this was first raised with me I was pretty disparaging. But I started to listen. These parents are scared to smack their children and paranoid that social workers will get involved and take their children away.”

Whilst smacking has not yet be outlawed in the UK, the smacker must not leave a mark (including reddening of the skin) on the body of the child and the decision on whether or not the smacking is reasonable can be up to a social worker if someone complains.

Putting my amusement of Mr Lammy squirming as his constituents attacked legislation passed by a governing party of which he was a member to one side, as a Libertarian the use of smacking is an issue where I find myself slightly confused.

At first glance, it certainly seems to violate the ‘harm’ principle as when you are dealing with children the action cannot be consensual*. However as parent you are responsible for looking after your children and doing what is best for them.

As no decent parent particularly wishes to harm their children, smacking is not a first response to misbehaviour but the last one. If you are dealing with a repeat offence and other approaches have already been tried, a few smacks on the bottom to associate – in the mind of the child – certain unwanted behaviour with pain has to be an option.

If the end result is a better behaved child then is it a entirely bad thing?

Given my personal dislike of children it is unlikely that I will ever be put in the position to have to smack any of my own but if I was then I think I would, but only as the option of last resort.

It is probable though that my views on the matter are clouded by my own childhood experiences. Both my brother and I found ourselves turned over dad’s knee occasionally whilst we were growing up and, with the benefit of hindsight, we probably deserved it each and every time. Yes, it bloody well hurt (dad used either his hand or the slipper) but I doubt we found ourselves in that position more than once every 6 months and only then because we had well and truly crossed an already defined line.

Did it do either of us any harm? Well we both got to 18 without getting into trouble with the police so in the long run I’d say that somehow my parents managed to do an ok job.

* Adults are, of course, a different matter but that is entirely between you and your partner(s) 😉

A quick thought on council house abuse

Housing Minister Grant Shapps has this morning announced that the government is considering criminalising subletting of council homes with the punishment potentially being up to 2 years in prison and fines of up to £50,000.

Given that those who are abusing the system are simply taking advantage of the fact that council rents are subsidised, why not just remove the subsidy and hence the distortion it makes in the market?

Or is that too simple?

On the difficulty of buying booze

Hello, my name is MG. I’m 33 years old and I need to tell you that sometimes I like to buy alcohol from my local Tesco supermarket.

In a country populated by grown-ups that had a government with a relaxed attitude to the drinking habits of the citizenry such a confession would obviously be unnecessary.

However as we all know the UK has none of these things which is why I find myself confronted, with increasing regularity, with demands from the checkout assistants that I produce ID to confirm that I am indeed old enough to purchase the wine or beer that sometimes falls into my shopping basket.

You would have thought that it should be fairly easy to realise that I am clearly an adult, even if you are unable to say exactly how far beyond the currently minimum legal age of 18 I am. Sadly this is not the case as my local store operates a policy of asking for ID if you don’t look over 25.

Yes, the first time I was asked I was flattered. However as I do not habitually carry ID with me – UK law not yet requiring me to do so – this quickly turned into irritation and these days I save time by just going straight to irritated.

On the first few times I argued but you quickly learn that arguing with a checkout assistant is like arguing with a brick wall (and their supervisors are no better) so I no longer bother and instead start unpacking any goods I have already placed into my bags back to the checkout before picking up my (now empty) bags and walking out of the store.

This inane idea of challenging anyone who might be under 25 is the follow up to the ‘Challenge 21’ policy and is the brainchild of the Retail of Alcohol Standards Group (RASG) and it is co-ordinated by the Wine and Spirit Trade Association (WSTA).

It’s purpose? To reduce the amount of alcohol sold to under 18s. It’s members? Most, if not every, supermarket chain operating in the UK.

Why does it exist? Because following a meeting with Charles Clarke, one of the many authoritarian Home Secretaries this country had to put up with under the last government, the retailers apparently mutually agreed to sell out and get into bed with government, rather than to stand up to them and live with the bullying that would have probably otherwise have followed. Thus ‘Challenge 21’ was born.

However as those blessed with half a brain cell and an understanding of history know, surrendering just means you get to spend a good long while being someone else’s bitch. In the case of the RASG this means that their work is supported by the Home Office, the Department of Culture, Media and Sport and the Department of Health.

This is apparently evidenced by the newer ‘Challenge 25‘ scheme:

However, with levels of sales to minors still not low enough and the personal consequences of illegal sales for the member of shop staff more severe, retailer employees requested a program which gives them a greater backing and a higher margin of error in challenging customers for proof of age.

Yes, when it is your paycheque on the line, you want to do your damnedest to ensure that you don’t get screwed over. Sadly it also means that common sense tends to go out of the window at the same time.

However how much did the RASG fight when the government of the day looked to start imposed these harsher penalties – or did their previous lack of doing so mean that they had no corner to fight?

I think it is probably safe to say that it was the government which decided that the level of alcohol sales to minors was still too high, although what that figure is I do not know – but one suspects that any figure above zero would be considered too high. Given that the utter elimination of alcohol sales to children is impossible, will the industry wake up to the situation they have found themselves in or are they now, like CAMRA, completely suffering from Stockholm Syndrome?

I meanwhile have decided that the time has come to find another supermarket to spend my money in.

The blame game

I’m sure that we have all by now seen the letter that an illiterate and unrepentant taxpayer money sink attempted to send to some* of his victims:

“I don’t know why I am writing a letter to you! I have been forced to write this letter by the ISSP.

“To be honest I’m not bothered or sorry about the fact I burgled your house. Basically it was your fault anyways.

“I’m going to run you through the dumb mistakes you made. Firstly, you didn’t drow (sic) your curtains which most people now (sic) to do before they go to sleep.

“Secondly your (sic) dumb you live in Stainburns a high risk burglary area, and your (sic) enough to leave your downstairs kitchen window open.

“I wouldn’t do that in a million years.

“But anyways I don’t feel sorry for you and I’m not going to show any syhmpth (sic) or remoers.(sic)

Quelle surprise: our thief doesn’t feel that he is to blame but that his victims are for making it so easy for him. This is an attitude apparently backed by courts in sentencing (12 month intensive supervision and surveillance plan), West Yorkshire Police who released this waste of dead tree ‘as a warning to householders to secure their properties’ and insurance companies who don’t pay out to those who they feel don’t make adequate attempts to secure their possessions.

Is this reasonable? How about we turn it around a bit…

You are a woman, dressed for night out and some despicable thug rapes you. In court he and his defence team blame you for the act, saying you were attired in such a way as to invite it.

Cue outrage.

We rightly consider blaming the rape victim for the fact that they were raped as outrageous. Why then this apparent acceptable of blaming the burglary victim for the burglary?

* I say some because I assume it is fairly likely that this oxygen thief has committed plenty more crimes.

Another day, another ban

The latest piece of bansturbation comes from the Association of British Insurers (ABI), the trade body representing much of the UK insurance industry.

In a statement released on Tuesday the ABI called for:

The ABI wants to see for learner drivers aged under 25:

  • A minimum one-year learning period before taking the driving test. A minimum learning period applies in many other countries.
  • A ban on taking intensive driving courses where this is the sole means of learning to pass the driving test. This would enable learner drivers to gain experience in a wider variety of road conditions.

For newly-qualified drivers aged under 25:

  • All new drivers should hold a graduated driving licence for two years, at the end of which they should be required to pass a second test to ensure that they are safe to drive on all types of roads.
  • The graduated driving licence would contain restrictions on the number of passengers that could be carried. This reflects the significantly increased accident risk when other passengers are in the car. It would also include restrictions on driving between 11pm – 4am, albeit with certain exemptions, such as where driving is necessary due to work.

Which is a long winded way of saying that new drivers from the younger end of the spectrum lack experience and so should have restrictions placed upon them. I’m sure though that their wish to only target these measures at the under 25s probably falls foul of age discrimination laws.

But why is the ABI proposing such changes? It can’t be that they are rent-seeking on behalf of themselves, seeing as a) not having car insurance is illegal and b) insurance premiums are rising year on year anyway*. Perhaps it simply is as Nick Starling, their Director of General Insurance and Health, says: “We must act to reduce the tragic loss of young lives on our roads”.

Will these proposals help with that though?

As we all know the only way to gain experience in a field is to spend time doing something so asking that learner drivers spend more time driving under supervision is perhaps a sensible measure albeit somewhat of a blunt instrument as some are quicker to learn than others. My concern though would be that it would simply delay the age at which the irresponsible subset hit the road unsupervised. If it were to happen though, then the intensive driving course would vanish, being no longer a viable idea. Also, isn’t helping learner drivers to pass their driving test the point of driving lessons, whether done in a week or over several months? The only people who are going to benefit from this are driving instructors as the poor bloodily wannabe motorist will havie to pay a lot more in start-up costs.

What about the restrictions on newly qualified drivers then? Limiting passenger numbers, banning them from the roads for certain hours of the night and, as the first line of the statement says “young novice drivers should not be allowed to drink any alcohol while driving”**.

As usual these do at first appear to be sensible but then you start thinking about them.

The passenger limit is obviously designed to stop carloads of teenagers and the accidents which have happened due to the drivers showing off to friends but will undoubtably hit more that just the intended targets. My brother, being a tee-totaler***, found himself being the designated driver of the family when out for meals once he was on the household insurance simply because it allowed the rest of us not to have to worry about how much we were drinking. Under these proposals such a thing wouldn’t be possible but is anyone really going to drive like a nutter with their parents in the car?

Similarly, the ban on night driving, whilst well intentioned, throws up questions. Are those who are working or going to/from work going to have to carry letters from their employer certifying that this is the case? What about those who intended to be home before curfew but get stuck in jams or break down? No doubt some women’s groups will protest that such a measure will make it more likely that some women will be attacked on the way home.

And as for the alcohol limit, well drink driving is already illegal anyway – as is dangerous driving.

What this statement hasn’t said is how they expect these measures, if implemented, to be enforced. Logically the only way for them to be so is via traffic police but those are a rare breed these days with most traffic offences being dealt with by roadside cameras – which as we all know are absolutely useless at catching people driving badly or under the influence. Given then that it is such driving that the ABI seeks to reduce, this seems like problem.

That is unless the ABI wants to put its money where its mouth is and take up traffic enforcement?

* The first year of insurance on my first car was my 20th birthday present from my parents. The car (a 1L lime-green Austin Metro) formerly belonged to my Nan and was almost as old as I was. The insurance was third party fire and theft rather than full comp and was about £500 as I recall – about 10 times what the car was worth.

Out of interest I just stuck my details into a car insurance website, taking myself back to being 20 again. Full comp on the last car I drove (1.4L Rover 25, 1999 model) came in at well over £2.5k.

Finding £500 for my second years insurance was difficult for me as a 21 year old fresh out of uni and, according to the inflation calculator that is £650 in today’s money. Finding 5 times that would be have been impossible. I can therefore see why some drive without insurance, even if I don’t necessarily condone it.

** I suspect they mean “young novice drivers should not be allowed to have any alcohol in their system whilst driving”.

*** It is standing family joke that he must be the milkman’s get.

The Glorious Bans

There is obviously something in the water cooler at the Home Office as all the ministers who sit in that particular hot seat appear to turn into swivelled-eyes fascist loons, hell bent on oppressing the population.

The current incumbent, one Theresa May, is best know for her taste in shoes, although she had a career in finance before becoming a professional politician.

Whilst we should not forget that soon after her appointment last year there was some good news, such as the scraping of ID Cards and ContactPoint, the attitude to freedom of speech, freedom of movement and freedom of association simply appears to be a continuation of the behaviour we came to expect from the last government.

In the last 18 months the bans of such activities have included:

  • Indian Muslim preacher Zakir Naik, in June 2010
  • Marches by the English Defence League (EDL) in Bradford, August 2010
  • The organisation Muslims Against Crusades (MAC), from midnight on 2011-11-11

Now I have no time for any of those people or organisations, considering them all to be utterly reprehensible, but banning them just tells them that you are afraid of what they might say or do.

I realise that it is a cliché to quote Voltaire in these situations but more appropriate words, I know not:

I do not agree with what you have to say, but I’ll defend to the death your right to say it.

On this day, when we remember those who died to protect us from those who would suppress us, it is disturbing to think that our politicians have completely forgotten that it is for freedoms such as this that millions of their countrymen and those from other countries around the world died.

Shame on them for doing so, shame on us for letting it happen.

Guardian press release regurgitation fail

On Tuesday the security firm Unisys released the latest results of what they call their bi-annual global Unisys Security Index, a ‘global study that provides insights into the attitudes of consumers on a wide range of security related issues‘.

Of the two questions that the survey asked, it was the second one about social media, which caught the attention of the MSM – or the Guardian anyway.

What did they ask?

During recent unrest in major UK cities, social networks such as Facebook and Twitter were used to coordinate criminal activity. Do you agree with these statements?

  • The authorities are playing catch up and need more resources to monitor online behaviour?
  • During outbreaks of unrest, providers should temporarily shut down social networks to prevent coordinated criminal activity?
  • The authorities should have open access to data about social network users in order to prevent coordinated criminal activity>
  • Providers of social networks should get more information on the people using their services before they allow use?

The Gruniad’s article on the matter says:

More than two-thirds of adults support the shutdown of social networks during periods of social unrest such as the riots in England this summer, new research has revealed.

A poll of 973 adults carried out for the online security firm Unisys found 70% of adults supported the shutdown of Twitter, Facebook and BlackBerry Messenger (BBM), while only 27% disagreed.

Which, after reading the report proper, only goes to confirm (as if confirmation were needed) that one should never take anything in the press at face value these days (if indeed one ever could).

The report says that the following percentages agreed with the four statements above: 49%, 48%, 46% and 42%.

Almost half I’ll grant you but hardly a majority, let alone 70%. Helpfully the report also gives some idea of how the responses breakdown by age. Not fully but enough to give us more of an idea of the views of each age group. It found that:

[The] desire to take strong measures rises with age:

  • More resources for police: 41% of those 18-24 to 52% of those 50-64 (seniors: 44%)
  • Temporary shut-downs during social unrest: from 28% of those 18-24 to 60% of seniors
  • Police monitoring: from 36% of those 18-24 to 52% of seniors
  • Background checks of new users: from 28% of those 18-24 to 49% of seniors.

Which shows us that a majority only exists as you go up the age scale. No surprises there. As for the 70% figure? The closest we get is for one age group on one statement.

Indeed the figure ’70’ doesn’t feature anywhere in the report, or assuming that the reporter James Ball (whose bio says that he ‘is a data journalist working for the Guardian investigations team. He joined the Guardian from Wikileaks, and the Bureau of Investigative Journalism’) didn’t get beyond it, the press release either.

About the only useful bit of the Guardian article therefore is the space filling rent-a-quote:

“It’s very worrying that people would believe shutting down social networks would be in any way desirable,” said Padraig Reidy, news editor of Index on Censorship. “The vast majority of social network use during the unrest was people spreading information and helping each other get home safely. These kinds of actions would weaken the UK’s position against authoritarian regimes who censor internet access. As we live more of our lives online, people should be conscious of the amount of power they’re potentially handing over to government.”

None of which I can disagree with at all.

Alcohol silliness in Scotland

Members of the Scottish Parliament (MSPs) will be, from Saturday, dealing with the law of unexpected consequences with respect of their changes last year to the Licensing (Scotland) Act 2005. The Alcohol Bill 2010 was aimed at banning the selling of alcoholic drinks at a discount and restricting alcohol advertising.

However, because it only applies in Scotland, online orders from companies who distribute from England are unaffected. One company who are therefore taking advantage of this is everyone’s favourite supermarket bogeyman, Tesco, who have sent out a marketing e-mail to customers saying:

“Great news! All orders placed at TescoWine by the case will still qualify for these discounts when applicable as your wine is dispatched to you from our distribution centre in Daventry, England.”

No doubt other supermarkets and online wine retailers will follow that lead, if they have not done so already.

Predictably the nu-puritans don’t like this with Jennifer Curran, from the fake charity Alcohol Focus Scotland, saying:

“Tesco’s move, which encourages the bulk-buying of alcohol, flies in the face of its claims to be a responsible retailer. This is a blatant attempt to get round the law.”

Blatant it might be but if your politicans are going to pass a law with such an obvious loophole then expect it to be used. Tesco are providing the method, the market will decide if it is worth their while or not.

The politicans also aren’t happy about it. A government spokesman said:

“Internet sales represent only a very small proportion of the alcohol sold in Scotland, but it is an area that we watch closely to see if further action is necessary.”

What further action you blithering morons? Do you seriously think you can stop this sort of thing from happening? If so, how? More regulation, perhaps this time concerning purchasing alcohol from other countries? Searching vehicles as they cross the border from England?

Answers on a postcard please to Alex Salmond…