What Charlie Stross did on his travels

For those who don’t know who he is, Charles (Charlie) Stross is an award winning British hard science fiction author (and thus a vaguely professional futurologist).

In August this year he spent some time in California, during which time he gave a keynote address to USENIX Security ’11 entitled ‘Network Security in the Medium Term: 2061–2561 AD‘.

Not just about network security, he takes the time to explain how he sees the world and the technology we currently know changing in the next 50 years, let alone the 500 after that.

The full text of his speech is available on his blog with audio and video available via the USENIX website.

I full recommend it if you are a fan of Stross and his works or wish to see what one person’s vision of the future is – especially as, at the lower boundary, almost everyone alive today who is under 40 will live to see how wrong (or right) he is.

For those who got through that and are still interested, he posted a follow-up on his blog a few days later wondering what the potential abundance of processing power we can expect to see in the even shorter term might mean.

Finally, for those who have made it this far, he did a reading from his latest book, Rule 34, to an audience in Cupertino. Afterwards he did a recorded Q&A with those who attended (split into three parts) and answers questions about current and emerging technologies, as well as being an author, amongst others.

A word of warning to those, like me, of a Libertarian bent: you may well find his opinion of us (which he describes in one section of part 2) a little annoying – but he is a socialist. 🙂

Fight – Update

Now that the 1st September has been and gone I thought I’d see what happened, if anything, to the young man whom the Essex Police Foarce had arrested and the CPS charged over encouraging people to join in a water fight.

In an attempt to refresh my memory on the details I looked at the original webpage, only to discover that some silent amendments have taken place and that the paragraph in question now has no reference to the water fight. Indeed it now reads (changes highlighted):

A 20-year-old man from Colchester who allegedly sent messages from a Blackberry encouraging violent disorder been charged with encouraging or assisting in the commission of an indictable only offence under the Serious Crime Act 2007. He has been conditionally bailed to appear at Colchester Magistrates’ Court on September 1.

Have they changed it because of the mockery? Let’s look at the report in the local paper and see what happened:

In a separate case Tommy Tucker, 20, was remanded in custody after being accused of encouraging the commission of an indictable offence.

The court heard he is accused of sending two messages on Blackberry messenger between August 7 and 10 which were intercepted by police.

Tucker did not enter a plea and will appear before Chelmsford Crown Court on November 7.

Essex Police had originally said his offences were linked to an attempt to start a water fight.

The force now says it was a different person who encouraged the water fight and that suspect has now been released without charge.

Well, well. It appears that someone either relayed the whole information to the publicity public relations department or that said department got their knickers in a twist.

The one piece of good news to come out of this is that the individual who was trying to organise the water fight wasn’t charged. Perhaps some common sense does exist?

Mobile manners

Debrett’s, that guide to everything you need to know about the upper strata of society and how to behave properly, has, it seems, finally gotten around to tackling the problem of mobile phone etiquette – or the lack there of.

Most people have, I’m sure, wanted at some point to remove a mobile from someone whose behaviour whilst using it is rude or obnoxious and place it forcibly about their person where the sun doesn’t shine. Personally my pet hate is those who use them in the quiet carriage on trains – and I would quite happily string anyone who does so up by their toes. 🙂

  • Think about what your ringtone says about you: head-banging rocker, fashion-conscious teenager, gamer, sci-fi nerd, smooth seducer, tv addict, ‘invisible’ (default)… Can you live with it?
  • If you’re embarrassed by your ringtone in certain situations (trains, office, when you’re visiting your mother) it’s almost certainly the wrong choice. Try again.
  • Monitor the volume of your ringtone; if it blares out and heads turn it’s too loud.
  • Remember there’s always vibrate. It may surprise your companions when you lurch – seemingly unprompted – to answer an invisible, silent phone, but at least they’ll be spared the ringtone.
  • Ensure that your mobile phone conversation is not disturbing other people. Intimate conversations are never appropriate in front of others – try and respect your own, and other people’s, privacy.
  • Don’t use foul language, have full-blooded rows, or talk about money, sex or bodily functions in front of witnesses.
  • Don’t use your phone in ‘quiet zones’ on trains. Even if you’re not in a designated zone, be aware that your voice will distract a peaceful carriage of newspaper-reading commuters. If the line is bad and conversations inaudible, explain that there’s a problem and hang up.
  • Your mobile phone is not a megaphone, so don’t shout…
  • If you lose reception, live with it. Refrain from shouting into a dead device, and ring the other person back as soon as you regain it, even if it’s only to say goodbye.
  • People in the flesh deserve more attention than a gadget, so wherever possible turn off your phone in social situations.
  • Don’t put your phone on the dining table, or glance at it longingly mid-conversation.
  • Don’t carry on mobile phone calls while transacting other business – in banks, shops, on buses and so on. It is insulting not to give people who are serving you your full attention.
  • Don’t make calls to people from inappropriate venues; a call from a bathroom is deeply off-putting.
  • Switch off your phone, or turn it on to vibrate, when you are going into meetings, theatres, cinemas and so on.
  • Bluetooth headsets are fine in the car (in fact they’re safe and legal).
  • If you are awaiting an important call when meeting someone socially, explain at the outset that you will have to take the call, and apologise in advance. Otherwise, excuse yourself and withdraw somewhere private to make or receive calls. Do not have a mobile phone conversation in front of your friends. It is the height of bad manners…

Quite frankly that list is just simple common sense and general courtesy. That it needs to be spelt out, does depressing, sum up much of what seems to be wrong with people.

Fight!

In the light of last week’s stupidities in London, Essex Police Foarce took great delight earlier this week informing the public what they are doing to stop such silliness breaking out in the county.

Sadly for them, much mockery was directed their way when it turned out that their preventative actions included such gems as this:

A 20-year-old man from Colchester who allegedly sent messages from a Blackberry encouraging people to join in a water fight has been charged with encouraging or assisting in the commission of an indictable only offence under the Serious Crime Act 2007. He has been conditionally bailed to appear at Colchester Magistrates’ Court on September 1.

Indeed, so mocked were they on twitter that they issued this follow-up:

Re water fight comments – police believe there may be more involved in light of recent disorder

Which rather sounds like someone went ‘Oh heck, this isn’t playing well. Better come up with something to make it sound more ominous.’

The Telegraph reports a spokesman as saying:

A spokesman for Essex Police indicated the BlackBerry Messenger network was under surveillance by police, saying: “I’m sure we are making efforts to monitor such correspondence, wherever they are,” he said.

He said the plans for a ‘water fight’ may have been a cover for rioting. “In the light of recent events, we would have to be careful that [the planned water fight] is not all that it seems,” he said.

As I doubt that Essex Police have the manpower to monitor everything on BBM, I’m going to assume that the ‘monitoring’ is, at best, someone flagging up key words and phrases and then asking RiM to match telephone numbers to names.

It will be interesting to see what happens come September 1st. Will the Police back this up with evidence, drop it or have the Magistrate laugh them out of court?

An unfortunate juxtaposition

Twitter Trends in the UK, afternoon of 4th August 2011

Shane Warne, Australian leg-spin bowler and one of the greatest bowlers of all time. A man whose name put the fear of God into every English batting line up for over a dozen years. A man whose test record against England stands at 36 matches, 1792.5 overs, 488 maidens, 4535 runs, 195 wickets at an average of 23.25, and whose Herculean efforts in the 2005 Ashes series where he took 40 of the 93 English wickets to fall in the 5 Tests almost single handedly denied them a first win against the Australians in 18 years.

Many a fan of English cricket may well have occasionally wished him ill as he once again ran through the ever crumbly middle order of the English cricket team in the 1990’s and early 2000’s but I like to think that none of them would have sandwiched him, as twitter did yesterday afternoon, between the Death Penalty and Capital Punishment.

The internet can, at times, be a very cruel place.

Blame the user, not the tool

We’ve all read newspaper stories about various unfortunate saps who have thrown parties whilst their parents have been away, only to find out that the quiet (in comparision to the outcome) gathering turns into a fairly hefty insurance claim and an indefinite grounding because word of mouth meant that lots of other people turned up as well.

When that word of mouth is the internet the number of uninvited guests can go up by at least one order of magnitude – and perhaps even two or three. But how does news of a social gathering for a smallish group of friends end up on the internet in the first place?

Because it was set up on Facebook of course. As ZDNet reports:

In March 2011, an Australian schoolgirl named Jess had to cancel her sweet 16 birthday party after her Facebook invitation went viral and over 200,000 people said they would show up at her house in Chatswood, New South Wales. She was lucky because Facebook made a point to help her out.

Last month, a young girl made the same mistake by posting a public invitation to her 16th birthday party. Around 1,500 to 1,600 uninvited guests turned up to her party in Hamburg, Germany. 100 police officers had to be deployed, and they detained 11 attendees on charges of aggravated battery and property damage. One police officer was injured, as were dozens of people who wore flip-flops and accidentally stepped on shards of glass from broken bottles. Two small fires had to be extinguished.

Shortly after, a spontaneous party in Wuppertal, Germany attracted some 800 guests, 41 of whom were taken into police custody and 16 of whom were injured. Hamburg authorities are currently preparing for a Facebook party planned for September 30 and are expecting an influx of up to 19,000 partygoers.

However rather than blame the social media behemoth – after all it is all about keeping people in contact – why not look at the person who set the event up in the first place?

Yes, Facebook does display the event creation page with the ‘Anyone can view and RSVP (public event)’ box checked by default but that is hardly a difficult thing to turn off, is it now? Indeed the author, in a spot of quick research (approximate duration one second), learnt that when that that box is unchecked a further, this time unchecked box, ‘Guests can invite friends’ is displayed. Now I realise that inherent laziness and unthinking stupidity doubtedly played a part in all of the incidences mentioned above but is unchecking a box on the internet really that difficult*?

Sadly, in isolated cases it seems so. However bar suggesting that Facebook doesn’t enable the ‘Anyone can view and RSVP (public event)’ box by default I can’t see any way to stop such acts of silliness.

Clearly then I am not cut out for elected office, at least not in Germany anyway:

“If public safety and order are endangered, then Facebook parties will have to be banned beforehand,” Lower Saxony’s Interior Minister Uwe Schünemann told the Welt am Sonntag newspaper, according to Deutsche Welle.

He is not an isolated case of stupidity either:

North Rhine-Westphalia’s Interior Minister Ralf Jäger agreed. “If, in advance of an announced Facebook party, there are concrete indications of a danger to the participants or third parties, then it is the duty of the local authorities to ban the party.”

Whilst yet another apparently wishes to put the cost of any post-party clear-up on to the person whose event it was:

Bavaria’s Interior Minister Joachim Herrmann warned that a harmless birthday invitation can quickly turn into a “massive security problem.” For the host that can sometimes lead to “immense costs,” as many simply want to go on a rampage, he claimed. “If there is an investigation into criminal offenses, the initiator should if possible pay for the costs of the police operation,” he told the same newspaper, according to The Local.

Thankfully there does seem to be at least one politician with some common sense:

“The simple fact that excesses happen on the sidelines of such events does not justify a general ban,” Wolfgang Bosbach, the chairman of the domestic affairs committee in parliament, told the daily Kölner Stadt Anzeiger, according to Spiegel. “There are also riots on the sidelines of football games and demonstrations but that does not mean that we should completely ban them.”

Still, if he can’t ban them then Herr Schünemann has a back-up plan: recommending the introduction of an “Internet Driving License” in schools that would explain the dangers of Facebook as he says that “Young people often don’t realize what they are getting into”.

That youngsters often don’t consider consequences of actions is hardly an earth shattering revelation but, unless they are terminally stupid, lessons, such as those taught by self-inflicted stupidity, tend to be learnt.

As one commentator on Slashdot summed it up:

This is all part of the German silly season (“Sommerloch”) – a period in summer when many political institutions are on vacation, so politicians which would normally be ignored can make it into the news – just because nobody important is active.

The statements in the article were all by conservatives in Germany (CDU + CSU). Given that it’s interesting that Dorothee Baer – secretary general of the CSU – has asked that “comments about the Internet should be made only by those who are familiar with it”. Sound advice.

And no, Germany is not considering banning facebook parties, this is just an attempt by some politicians to get noticed.

Seems strangely familiar, doesn’t it?

* I have no idea what Facebook’s accessibility is like so the visual-impaired will have to confirm if it is any more difficult for them than the average sighted user.

Freedom of Speech?

Luke O’Donoughoe, a particularly brain-dead specimen of humanity if one is to go by the picture of him in the Daily Fail, has gained himself an (no doubt) unwanted footnote in history by being the first person to be banned from a football ground for life because of remarks he made on twitter.

That ban has now been followed up with a criminal record ‘for sending an offensive message by public communication network under the Communications Act 2003’ and 120 hours of community service.

His crime? In the now deleted tweet (or tweets) he referred to a recent club signing using a word beginning with ‘N’ which is deemed to be offensive. Whether the player that the remarks were about saw them is unknown but what is known is that lots of others took offense on his behalf and it is their anger which has led us to where we are now.

That the word has history is undeniable but for all of that it is still a single word – and such a small word at that, consisting as it does, of only 6 letters and two syllables. Words though convey meanings and some, such as the one O’Donoughoe used, contain a lot more information than others.

Should he be punished though for using it? Indeed should anyone be punished for using words that others may deem to be offensive – especially if the person to whom they were directed didn’t see and/or hear them? Is second-hand offensiveness now as permissable in this country as second-hand smoking?

If we are truely a society that permits freedom of speech then people should be allowed to use the words without fearing that the State will punish them for it.

And before anyone shouts at me, I am not saying that the use of them should be consequence free. As the (I presume) owners of their ground, Norwich City are perfectly within their rights to ban O’Donoughoe from their property for life and, if being banned from the home ground of the team he supports isn’t enough, the internet will undoubtedly make sure that his stupidity – or at least some reference to it – is always there for others to see.

Being ostracised by society is a far more effective punishment for your sins than anything the State can impose.

Watching the Detectives Rubbish

Living in Britain I as do I have become accustomed to the fact that, however much I don’t like it, I am spied upon on a daily basis by surveillance cameras operated by all sorts of public bodies and private companies under the nebulous idea of ‘safety’. How a fixed camera emplacement, unlikely to ever be watched in real time 24/7, keeps me safe is, as yet, a still unanswered question.

It should then really come as no surprise to me to learn that Newcastle University – or rather their School of Computing Science and their Culture Lab in conjunction with the universities of Lincoln and Duisburg-Essen – have decided to take surveillance one step further and are placing camera phones in bins – all in the name of encouraging recycling.

The ‘BinCam‘ (as it is somewhat obviously named) scheme works by having an app on the ‘phone rigged to take a photo of the contents every time the lid closes. The picture is then uploaded to Facebook for anyone to who adds the BinCam app to their profile to view. It is also sent to Amazon’s Mechanical Turk where a new Human Intelligence Test is created and some lucky soul somewhere gets to identify the contents of the bin (food, recyclable items) visible in the image. Two scores are then awarded to each bin – one for each category aforementioned – and at the end of each week the bins are ranked in a league.

So far five student households have signed up to the scheme and Anja Thieme, post-grad student and project leader says of it so far:

“A few times we even saw people throwing something away and then going back into the bin to take it out again.? During the focus groups, the students said they felt like the bin was watching them and that it definitely made them think twice about what they were throwing away.?? At the same time they felt motivated by the online league table to recycle more and improve their rating.”

No dear, what we have here is not a sudden conversion to the delights of recycling and the joys of sustainability by the participating students but rather a bunch of score whores all obsessed with being the top dog.

No matter what the field of human endeavour, put enough people in the same place and competition will always result – especially if there is some form of reward involved.

Nevertheless the university intends to extend this ‘competition’ to more student houses at the start of the next academic year with their ‘Waste Manager’ – a title that surely speaks for itself – saying:

“Students have busy lives and recycling competes with other demands. Anything that makes recycling easier is good – but when it is fun and innovative like BinCam it really encourages participation. The use of Facebook and the community peer pressure is fascinating and I am looking forward to introducing the application to other parts of the campus.”

Busy lives? Other demands? Unless things have changed radically from my own days then those demands are likely to be nothing more strenuous than drinking, surfing the ‘net, playing computer games and watching lots of TV. Plus some studying.

The idea is novel, I’ll grant you that, but how long until the novelty wears off and the students get sick of it? Will their new found enthusiasm for recycling hold or will they simply go back to what they were doing before?

Of course, if it does take off, then how long before some idiot civil servant or politician either here or in the EU decides to make the whole thing compulsory – and backed up with the obligatory fines for those who step out of line?

An Internet Storm in a Teacup

In a textbook example of how a story of ‘ifs’, ‘buts’ and ‘maybes’ can get out of hand, a report in the Daily Mail on May 1st about a potential tightening up of what can – or can’t be show pre-watershed caused a small amount of righteous fury yesterday.

Given that this is the Mail, they led the story with the idea that lesbian kisses could be banned from being shown under this potential change and this was picked up by The Sun which initially didn’t bother to pass on more information than just that, preferring instead to run with the outrage of an soap opera actress, who portrays a lesbian, who hadn’t read the full story either.

Cue snowball effect as various right-on internet publications, which also hadn’t bothered reading the story, all accused David Cameron and the Tories of going back to the days where they were the ‘Nasty Party’.

As the Daily Mail was at the forefront of the whole Section 28 palaver in the mid-80s and has been regularly accused of being economical with the truth by groups claiming to champion the rights of minorities you would be forgiven for thinking that such organisations wouldn’t have taken the story that they got second or third hand at face value.

Indeed, the whole basis for the original Daily Mail report is a single, anonymous source apparently close to the Bailey Review, commissioned by the government last year to ‘look at the pressures on children to grow up too quickly’, who said that:

For some parents, what has been considered acceptable in the past – such as that Brookside kiss – is not appropriate for children to see early in the evening.

And that ladies and gentlemen is it. A single line which stirred up a small internet frenzy. I suppose it would have been a bigger one but for the apparent death of someone in Pakistan which mean that, in the end, almost no-one was listening to the howls of anguish being generated by a small number of interested parties.

Shockingly, although you could have been forgiven for missing it, that wasn’t all that the anonymous source had to say. Not that the interest groups cared. Indeed I’m not sure the Mail did either as they probably thought that their job was done after giving lesbians and most of their male readership heart attacks at the thought of having to find pictures of two women kissing somewhere other than on prime time television.

Other things apparently in the firing line include raunchy dance routines on pre-watershed TV, sexual explicit advertisements in public places (by which they are generally referring to large posters of lingerie clad women) as well as a crackdown on internet pornography by enabling parents to ask web service providers to block obscene websites ‘at source’ rather than relying on parental controls.

Strangely there were no cries of outrage at any of that. No suggestions that ISPs shouldn’t exist to backstop parents who are too lazy to use controls that already exist to restrict what their children look at online. No thoughts on whether hiding away the semi-naked form is all just a touch puritan. No complaints about the potential suggestiveness of dance routines performed by the likes of Christina Aguilera and Rihanna.

Honestly, anyone would think that those making a fuss didn’t care about anything outside of justifying their own blinkered existence…