On the difficulty of buying booze

Hello, my name is MG. I’m 33 years old and I need to tell you that sometimes I like to buy alcohol from my local Tesco supermarket.

In a country populated by grown-ups that had a government with a relaxed attitude to the drinking habits of the citizenry such a confession would obviously be unnecessary.

However as we all know the UK has none of these things which is why I find myself confronted, with increasing regularity, with demands from the checkout assistants that I produce ID to confirm that I am indeed old enough to purchase the wine or beer that sometimes falls into my shopping basket.

You would have thought that it should be fairly easy to realise that I am clearly an adult, even if you are unable to say exactly how far beyond the currently minimum legal age of 18 I am. Sadly this is not the case as my local store operates a policy of asking for ID if you don’t look over 25.

Yes, the first time I was asked I was flattered. However as I do not habitually carry ID with me – UK law not yet requiring me to do so – this quickly turned into irritation and these days I save time by just going straight to irritated.

On the first few times I argued but you quickly learn that arguing with a checkout assistant is like arguing with a brick wall (and their supervisors are no better) so I no longer bother and instead start unpacking any goods I have already placed into my bags back to the checkout before picking up my (now empty) bags and walking out of the store.

This inane idea of challenging anyone who might be under 25 is the follow up to the ‘Challenge 21’ policy and is the brainchild of the Retail of Alcohol Standards Group (RASG) and it is co-ordinated by the Wine and Spirit Trade Association (WSTA).

It’s purpose? To reduce the amount of alcohol sold to under 18s. It’s members? Most, if not every, supermarket chain operating in the UK.

Why does it exist? Because following a meeting with Charles Clarke, one of the many authoritarian Home Secretaries this country had to put up with under the last government, the retailers apparently mutually agreed to sell out and get into bed with government, rather than to stand up to them and live with the bullying that would have probably otherwise have followed. Thus ‘Challenge 21’ was born.

However as those blessed with half a brain cell and an understanding of history know, surrendering just means you get to spend a good long while being someone else’s bitch. In the case of the RASG this means that their work is supported by the Home Office, the Department of Culture, Media and Sport and the Department of Health.

This is apparently evidenced by the newer ‘Challenge 25‘ scheme:

However, with levels of sales to minors still not low enough and the personal consequences of illegal sales for the member of shop staff more severe, retailer employees requested a program which gives them a greater backing and a higher margin of error in challenging customers for proof of age.

Yes, when it is your paycheque on the line, you want to do your damnedest to ensure that you don’t get screwed over. Sadly it also means that common sense tends to go out of the window at the same time.

However how much did the RASG fight when the government of the day looked to start imposed these harsher penalties – or did their previous lack of doing so mean that they had no corner to fight?

I think it is probably safe to say that it was the government which decided that the level of alcohol sales to minors was still too high, although what that figure is I do not know – but one suspects that any figure above zero would be considered too high. Given that the utter elimination of alcohol sales to children is impossible, will the industry wake up to the situation they have found themselves in or are they now, like CAMRA, completely suffering from Stockholm Syndrome?

I meanwhile have decided that the time has come to find another supermarket to spend my money in.

Thoughts on the National Minimum Wage

According to news today, the Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg is to offer bribes subsidies to employers of up to £2,275 to employ some of the estimated 1.163 millions young people not in education, employment or training (NEETs).

Doing some back of a fag-paper calculations using a 40 hour week for 52 weeks a year (a total of 2080 hours) as a guideline:

Age Group 18 – 20 21+
National Minimum Wage (NMW) (£) 4.98 6.08
Yearly Wage (£) 10,358.40 12,646.40
Employers NI (£)* 453.52 769.27
Total Cost to Employer (Year) (£) 10,811.92 13,415.67
Total Cost to Employer (Hour) (£) 5.20 6.45
6 Month Cost (£) 5,405.96 6,707.84
6 Month Cost after subsidy (£) 3,130.96 4,4323.84
Hourly Wage after subsidy (£) 3.01 4.26
Difference between pre and post subsidy Hourly Wage (£) 2.19 2.19
Percentage of pre subsidy wage (%) 42.12 33.95
Percentage of post subsidy wage (%) 72.75 51.41

* Figures obtained via Listen to taxman

If the government is having to subsidise employment for some people by at least a third, the only logical conculsion surely is that the NMW is too high?

Occupy Southend

Southend town centre, hardly the world’s most salubrious place, did, very briefly, almost find itself on Sunday playing host to the latest outbreak of the ‘Occupy’ disease which is afflicting some of the more affluent* countries of the world.

Started (where else?) via facebook** on 12th November with this fabulous posting:

Occupy Southend starts Sunday 20th November, 2011. For too long now the ordinary people of this country have suffered at the hands of the very few. We are the many, and as such we will occupy Southend. The banks and the corporations have created a world not fit for purpose, and we won’t tolerate their way of greed, and their way of control any more. Each Occupy gathering around the country and around the world has developed its own personality, and we in Southend will naturally create our own. Our aim is to be all inclusive of the people of Southend, to be a receiver of information as well as a giver – to be a beacon of light, and a vehicle for change. As human beings we are amazing. We can create a thousand different systems to live under – and we’ve ended up with this rotten one. No more will we extend power over us to the few. Our power must return to us, and from use of our own power we’ll develop a world centred on the heart and not the corporate bank balance. Come join us at Occupy Southend. Post your views now. Offer your thoughts. We’ll be updating regularly each day from Tuesday. Until then spread the news far and wide. The tents are coming to town!

Now some of that actually makes sense, assuming that it means the crony capitalist system we have and isn’t simply a swipe attack on the whole idea of free-market capitalism in general.

It does rather descend into fantasy though when it starts wittering on about being a beacon of light and a vehicle for change. In Southend? Talk about delusions of grandeur.

That though was probably the high point. From then on it was standard stuff about when and where with cross posts of items from the St. Paul’s camp before the penultimate posting soon after midday on the following Saturday:

URGENT

Late last night Occupy Southend was made aware of a threat, from a known extremist organisation, to hijack tomorrow’s occupation. Since then we have been trying to establish the legitimacy of this threat and we now believe it may well manifest.

The Occupy Movement is peaceful and non-confrontational, and as such refuses to facilitate those who would seek to use violence and confrontation. Occupy Southend would never bring violence and confrontation to this town, and so we give notice that tomorrow’s assembly at 2pm, outside Southend Victoria station, and the ensuing occupation, is regrettably cancelled.

To those who we are not aware of, but who were set to join us tomorrow, we trust you will understand our reasoning. The opportunity will arise again to Occupy Southend. Please contact us through occupysouthend@hushmail.com

Our message remains one of peace, and one of continual respectful debate. We are resolute and strong. We are many. They are few. There’s is a house of cards. It will inevitably fall.

A threat from a well known extremist organisation? Really? What are we talking about here? IRA? ETA? Al-Qaeda? The local Rotary Club? Or just the Southend yoof? Aside from people taking the preverbal I really can’t see what sort of credible threat might possibly exist. Heck, you conveniently planned the thing to start after any alcohol fuelled silliness of a Friday or Saturday night. Or was that because you wanted to get drunk then yourself?

I would suggest that a far more plausible explanation would be that almost no-one was going to turn up, thus resulting in the whole thing being a bit of a damp squib. I await to see if the idea will be raised again but I won’t hold my breath.

* According to Wikipedia a few people in Columbia and Mongolia also appear to have got in on the act/jumped on a passing bandwagon.

** And there was me thinking that twitter was where all the cool people hung out these days.

Cameron and his trouble with women

If the Daily Fail is to be believed, iDave is to appoint a female Special Advisor to assess the impact of every Coalition policy on women.

Why?

Because their polling numbers amongst women are apparently quite low, coming in at, depending on which article I read, between 34% and 43%.

Obviously it goes without saying that something like 35% of women (and men) won’t vote for him (or, to be more accurate, a member of his party) simply because of the colour of the rosette on offer. What he doesn’t want to lose are the floating voters, that 15% or so who aren’t so tribal and vote depending on which way the wind is blowing.

And it seems that they don’t like him.

To be fair I can see why, given that this government is, amongst other things, driving the female state pension age towards equality faster than the previous one whilst taking measures to cap benefits which they claimed and pruning the civil service jobs which they did.

We are all, to some degree, conservative, disliking change – especially when it affects us. Thus changes, however necessary they are, mean that politicians risk alienating those voters who are affected by them. Alienate them too much and you lose elections… and it is that thought which causes consternation amongst all politicians and their advisors, not just Cameron.

Their frantic vote scrabbling therefore begs two questions:

Firstly (and I realise I am being flippant here) are we also going to get special advisors to assess how changes impact on the disabled, those of different ethnicities, sexualities, hair colour and however else humanity wishes to group itself?

Secondly (and more seriously) was it the short-term thinking of our politicians which drove the short-term thinking of the voters and thus landed us in the mess, or the other way around?

The Glorious Bans

There is obviously something in the water cooler at the Home Office as all the ministers who sit in that particular hot seat appear to turn into swivelled-eyes fascist loons, hell bent on oppressing the population.

The current incumbent, one Theresa May, is best know for her taste in shoes, although she had a career in finance before becoming a professional politician.

Whilst we should not forget that soon after her appointment last year there was some good news, such as the scraping of ID Cards and ContactPoint, the attitude to freedom of speech, freedom of movement and freedom of association simply appears to be a continuation of the behaviour we came to expect from the last government.

In the last 18 months the bans of such activities have included:

  • Indian Muslim preacher Zakir Naik, in June 2010
  • Marches by the English Defence League (EDL) in Bradford, August 2010
  • The organisation Muslims Against Crusades (MAC), from midnight on 2011-11-11

Now I have no time for any of those people or organisations, considering them all to be utterly reprehensible, but banning them just tells them that you are afraid of what they might say or do.

I realise that it is a cliché to quote Voltaire in these situations but more appropriate words, I know not:

I do not agree with what you have to say, but I’ll defend to the death your right to say it.

On this day, when we remember those who died to protect us from those who would suppress us, it is disturbing to think that our politicians have completely forgotten that it is for freedoms such as this that millions of their countrymen and those from other countries around the world died.

Shame on them for doing so, shame on us for letting it happen.

Rowan Williams fantasies again

Given that an orgy of stupidity has been in progress in and around St. Paul’s Cathedral for just over two weeks now it is somewhat surprising that it has taken the Church of England’s CEO, a man given to saying foolish things, this long to open his mouth and insert his foot.

However presented once more with the pulpit of the MSM (in this case in the shape of the Financial Times) from which to preach, the Archbishop of Canterbury has gratefully seized the opportunity to do just that and did, yesterday morn, issue a sermon.

If his article was full of waffle about what has been going on at the Cathedral then we could – and would – quite happily have ignored him. However as he couldn’t help but slip in his opinions on matters temporal, viz banking and economics, he once again needs to be taken to task.

There is help to be had from a bold statement on our financial situation emerging last week from the Vatican. This document, from the Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace, is entitled ‘Towards Reforming the International Financial and Monetary Systems in the Context of Global Public Authority‘. It contains, along with some sharp critical analysis a rather utopian vision of global governance and regulation. But, more importantly, it offers three quite specific recommendations that seek not to change everything at once but simply to minimize the damage of certain current practices and assumptions in the immediate future.

Ah, so it turns out that Williams hasn’t had an original idea (perish the thought) and is instead taking his lead from the Vatican. That is, surely, more then enough reason to have Brenda, as Chairman of the Board, send him to the Tower so that he might consider the error of his ways…

His future, or lack there of, aside what are the papist ideas which he wishes us to consider?

One is something we have now heard clearly from many sources – a plea now endorsed by the Vickers Commission that routine banking business should be clearly separated operationally from speculative transactions. The rolling-up of individual and small-scale savings into high-risk and high-return adventures in the virtual economy is one of the more obvious danger areas in the light of recent years. Early Government action in this area is needed.

Remind me, how much did the ‘casino’ arm of Northern Rock lose? How much did the retail arm of Lehman Brothers lose?

A second plea is for the recapitalization of banks with public money to be accompanied by obligations on the banks to help re-invigorate the real economy.

No and no. No bank should have been propped up by the poor bloody tax payer, being instead allowed to fail. Savers would have been fine up to the tune of £35,000 and investors, as is the case with any failed business, would have lost out. However what’s done is done there (sadly) but why should these newly acquired state assets be forced to lend money? You can’t re-capitalise them, thus allowing them to rebuild their balance sheets, yet expect them to lend money to all and sundry once again.

But the third suggestion is probably the most far-reaching. The Vatican statement strongly backs the proposal of a Financial Transaction Tax – a ‘Tobin Tax’ or, popularly, a ‘Robin Hood Tax’ in the form in which it has been talked about most recently. This means a comparatively small rate of tax (0.05%) being levied on share, bond, and currency transactions and their derivatives, with the resulting funds being designated for investment and development in the ‘real’ economy, domestically and internationally. The modest rate of taxation conceals the high levels of return that could be expected (some $410bn globally on one estimate).

I don’t know where the Archbishop is getting those figures from but even if we give him the benefit of the doubt and say that it isn’t a retired tax accountant from Wandsworth, that $410 billion is a rather high number. Using the 2010 GDP figures we can see calculate that the $410bn figure is 0.65% of the total, which is somewhat above the theoretical 0.05% tax rate given.

Thankfully, via Clifford Chance, who have looked at the EU’s own analysis, we have some more realistic figures available to us:

The Commission paper estimates the tax itself would raise €16bn to €43bn, but the figure is very dependent upon the degree of dislocation, and previous reports suggest the Commission’s original estimate was €10bn. Revenues would be shared between Member States and the EU (partly reducing national contributions).

The Commission does not however estimate the reductions in receipts from other taxes. Stamp duty revenues are currently quite significant – £4bn in the UK alone. Add to this reduced corporation and personal tax receipts – the Commission’s impact assessment anticipates a reduction in economic output of almost 1.8% – and it seems likely the revenue effect of the FTT will be negative.

The FTT is therefore perhaps the first tax in history which is being proposed in the knowledge it will reduce tax revenues.

A tax that loses use money? That’ll scupper any chance of more money for government ‘investment’ then, won’t it?

Other commentators such as Charles Orton-Jones and Tim Worstall also agree, pointing out the cost of this will be passed on to you and I as customers, employees and shareholders as well as the potential loss of jobs (and thus tax revenues) if banks, hedge funds and other such financial companies decide to relocate to less hostile climates.

In conclusion I therefore repeat to the silly old fool the advice I gave him back in April

May I kindly suggest to the Archbishop that he sticks to his job and doesn’t stick his head above the parapet again unless he has actually thought about what it is that he is saying?

in the hope that this time he will take it? However as I doubt he will I look forward to filleting his twaddle the next time he decides to place his foot in his mouth.

Time Troubles

As we woke up this morning having once again returned to Greenwich Mean Time (GMT) the argument about whether we should shift from this to Central European Time (CET) was once again rearing its head.

The stalking horse for this current push to switch to the time zone used by much of Western Europe is Rebecca Harris, MP for Castle Point and a member of the 2010 Conservative intake, who is championing it as a Private Member’s Bill. As a quick check of her voting record confirms* that she is nothing more than lobby fodder in search of a place on the payroll, it is reasonably safe to say that this bill has had the backing of ministers from the very start.

Firstly some history…

The adoption of a standard time zone in the UK is still a relatively modern idea with GMT only becoming the official time zone of Great Britain in 1880, just a few years before the International Meridian Conference of 1884 established the Greenwich Meridian as 0° longitude.**

British Summer Time (BST) came about in 1916 as part of the amendments to the Defence of the Realm Act and was done originally in an attempt to save fuel (and thus money).

On three occasions since then the UK has moved away from the GMT/BST switch:

  1. During WWII BST remained in force throughout the winter of 1940. This was in the spring of 1941 by an advancement to ‘British Double Summer Time’ or GMT + 2.
  2. The summer of 1947 when, as the result of fuel shortages, the clocks went forward and back twice.
  3. October 1968 to October 1971 when the country stayed on BST rather than reverting to GMT.

And now back to the present…

Harris’ bill opens by saying that it:

Require[s] the Secretary of State to conduct a cross-departmental analysis of the potential costs and benefits of advancing time by one hour for all, or part of, the year; to require the Secretary of State to take certain action in the light of that analysis; and for connected purposes.

One of the first things to note here is that ‘or part of’ is redundant. Thanks to Directive 2000/84/EC we can no longer repeat the Wilson government’s experiment of 1968-70

Article 1
For the purposes of this Directive “summer-time period” shall mean the period of the year during which clocks are put forward by 60 minutes compared with the rest of the year.

Article 2
From 2002 onwards, the summer-time period shall begin, in every Member State, at 1.00 a.m., Greenwich Mean Time, on the last Sunday in March.
Article 3

From 2002 onwards, the summer-time period shall end, in every Member State, at 1.00 a.m., Greenwich Mean Time, on the last Sunday in October.

and as such any change would have to apply all year round.

The body of the bill asks for:

  1. A cost/benefit analysis on switching to CET (we can ignore the request for an assessment on whether the dates on which BST starts and ends are optimal for reasons already stated above) and wants this information published within three months of the passing of the act.
  2. That this analysis is then inspected by an ‘independent’ commission of no more than 12 members plus an item of furniture*** and they must report back within 6 months of appointment.
  3. If the commission concludes that a switch is a good idea then it must be implemented for a trial period of three years. No later than six months before the trial period ends the success (or otherwise) of it must be reviewed and no later three months before it is due to end should the option of making the change permanent be laid before the house.

All of which of course sounds very reasonable.

On Conservative Home this time last year Harris wrote:

The Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents and all the road safety organisations conclude that it will save up to 80 lives from fatal road accidents and prevent many more serious injuries, by adding more daylight to the busier afternoon rush hour. Tourism organisations believe it will increase tourist revenues by as much as £4 billion and create up to 80,000 jobs in the industry, by extending the season and letting attractions stay open an hour longer every day. Environmentalists like Lighter Later and Green Peace say that less use of electric light during the evening peak time will not only reduce energy bills but also help us meet our carbon emission targets.

That really is checking boxes, isn’t it? Fewer deaths, more jobs, environmental benefits, lower energy bills… it truly sounds like a modern miracle!

Lets think about them more closely shall we?

The 80 avoidable deaths is remarkably concise and, going by the 2010 figure of 1,857 deaths, would mean a reduction of over 4%. Sounds good then but what I couldn’t see from a brief scan of the RoSPA website was when this calculation was made and with which year’s road death stats; how the figure was reached, let alone what the margin or error is; and if this is the balance (or not) between extra deaths in the morning and fewer in the evening. If anyone can point me in the direction of answers to these questions I would be grateful.

An extra 80,000 jobs? Attractions open longer? Really? We aren’t increasing the length of the day, just altering which hours are daylight and which aren’t. Ergo tourist attractions, bars and restaurants aren’t necessarily going to be open longer hours and thus won’t be employing more people. Even if they extend their opening hours, I would expect the first course of action would be to have existing employees to cover the extra hours.

It is her final point, the environmental one, which I suspect will carry more weight – depending on how they spin it. If they go for the cost argument, i.e. potentially lower energy bills, then there is plenty of scope for self-interest given the direction of travel of energy bills in this country (one factor in this being the inclusion of green taxes to subsidise otherwise unviable schemes). A cynical person might also wonder if it is simply a cunning plan to extend the life of various plants through reduced usage and thus less yearly emissions?

In the end though this argument boils down to which hours of the day do we wish to see sunlight.

Being London centric for a moment, on the longest day of the year sunrise is shortly before 0445 and sunset shortly after 2120. On the shortest day it rises at shortly before 0805 and sets shortly before 1555. During August, supposedly the height of summer****, sunrise changes from approximately 0525 to 0610 with sunset changing from approximately 2050 to 1950

Move those times forward a hour makes little difference to anyone in the middle of June unless they are early risers but for the best part of a month (mid December to mid January) we’ll have sunrise not occurring until after the working day is generally considered to have started and sunset occurring just before it theoretically ends.*****

Going to work in the dark and coming home in the dark? Been there, done that****** and it isn’t fun. I’ll take the earlier sunrise during the winter months and the bit of sunshine that I get with it before I arrive in the office to lighter evenings throughout the year. And as for waking up in May and finding it is still dark outside? Thanks but no thanks!

For me this seems to be a case of once again trying to fix something which isn’t broken and as such I can’t see the point of it.

* I use ‘confirms’ rather ‘reveals’ because she is my parent’s MP and via them (mother a member of the local association, both of them friends with most of the association’s leading members) I am well aware of how much she sucks up to iDave. Final confirmation (as if it was needed) came when I saw her name on the list of those who opposed the backbench motion for a referendum on the EU.

** The French, being French wanted it to be Paris but they lost the vote. It then took them 17 years finally admit defeat. This is probably close to being a national record for them.

*** “The Commission shall consist of a Chair and no more than 12 other members appointed by the Secretary of State.” This government really is committed to equal opportunities!

**** Recent years to the contrary.

***** I can’t recall ever being out of the office at 1700.

****** A temp job in a plastics moulding factory. 12 hour days from 0700 to 1900 for £4/hour. I lasted 2 days.

Alcohol silliness in Scotland

Members of the Scottish Parliament (MSPs) will be, from Saturday, dealing with the law of unexpected consequences with respect of their changes last year to the Licensing (Scotland) Act 2005. The Alcohol Bill 2010 was aimed at banning the selling of alcoholic drinks at a discount and restricting alcohol advertising.

However, because it only applies in Scotland, online orders from companies who distribute from England are unaffected. One company who are therefore taking advantage of this is everyone’s favourite supermarket bogeyman, Tesco, who have sent out a marketing e-mail to customers saying:

“Great news! All orders placed at TescoWine by the case will still qualify for these discounts when applicable as your wine is dispatched to you from our distribution centre in Daventry, England.”

No doubt other supermarkets and online wine retailers will follow that lead, if they have not done so already.

Predictably the nu-puritans don’t like this with Jennifer Curran, from the fake charity Alcohol Focus Scotland, saying:

“Tesco’s move, which encourages the bulk-buying of alcohol, flies in the face of its claims to be a responsible retailer. This is a blatant attempt to get round the law.”

Blatant it might be but if your politicans are going to pass a law with such an obvious loophole then expect it to be used. Tesco are providing the method, the market will decide if it is worth their while or not.

The politicans also aren’t happy about it. A government spokesman said:

“Internet sales represent only a very small proportion of the alcohol sold in Scotland, but it is an area that we watch closely to see if further action is necessary.”

What further action you blithering morons? Do you seriously think you can stop this sort of thing from happening? If so, how? More regulation, perhaps this time concerning purchasing alcohol from other countries? Searching vehicles as they cross the border from England?

Answers on a postcard please to Alex Salmond…