Local Election 2011 Round-Up: The Result

Those who read my taking apart of election leaflets of three of the five candidates standing in my ward on Thursday may wish to know the outcome. So, without further ado, here it is (names redacted to protect the guilty):

Party Votes
Independent 835
Labour 623
Conservative 415
Liberal Democrat 265
Green 217

35 ballot papers were spoilt and the turnout was 31.59%.

I’m happy to see that none of the cretins who bothered to leaflet me got in and, theoretically, I have no problems with being represented by an Independent although I may have to write to him and ask him what his platform was.

The borough however is still true blue Conservative (hardly a surprise) and the only change in the seat numbers is that the Liberal Democrats are down two whilst the Independents are up two. The good news though is that the one woman walking disaster area known as Anna Waite was quite comprehensively thrown out by her electorate.

Local Election 2011 Round-Up: Liberal Democrats

Also making a late dash for my vote are the Liberal Democrats and given the crudity of the leaflet (an A4 bit of paper that has obviously been run off on a standard laser printer) shoved through my letterbox it seems they either forgot or had little to no money to spend. Still, let’s not pre-judge them completely. It may (no laughing at the back) contain something that convinces me to vote for the candidate.

Like the two previous candidates mentioned he also lives in the ward, next door the the Labour candidate as it turns out. That must make for interesting conversations across the fence, no doubt. He also claims to know first hand the problems those of us in the ward face. Strangely I don’t ever recall speaking to him, let alone meeting him so I can only assume that he is a mind reader if he knows what problems I do (or don’t) have.

The only local issues he mentions though are the library (he ups the ante by suggesting it is in need of saving) and the rubbish so it seems that perhaps he and his neighbour do get along quite well.

The next half page covers the result of last year’s local elections when the Lib Dem candidate in this ward narrowly beat the Conservative one and in the process ousted the sitting Independent. Unsurprisingly last year’s victor is enthusiastically endorsing his party compatriot.

This is followed by the need to explain the break down of parties and seats within the ward and I am told that the Lib Dems are neck and neck with the Conservatives in the west of the borough. No mention of the eastern half but I suppose that their utter lack of a councillor out that way is not something they’d wish to trumpet. I am also told that only the Lib Dems can beat the Tories in this ward. No mention that the sitting councillor is an Independent, this is supposedly just a straight slugfest between two parties in collation nationally.

Not that the leaflet mentions the national situation anywhere. There isn’t a sniff of anything from Liberal Democrat high command anywhere on it. Too embarrassed perhaps? Hoping against hope that if they don’t mention it then perhaps the locals won’t give them too much of a kicking? Who knows.

It concludes by making an attack on the sitting administration, accusing them of incompetence, bad decision making and money wasting. All standard fair to be honest, even if former council leader Anna Waite does seem to have spent a lot of time in the local press for all the wrong reasons. However what it doesn’t say, amongst the claims that a Liberal Democrat administration would make things better in the borough, is that the maths is, I believe, against them. The best they can do is become the biggest party and to do that they will need to hang on to their existing seats and win almost everywhere else. That doesn’t seem likely.

Local Election 2011 Round-Up: Labour Party

With barely any time to go before voting day, the Labour Party tried to make a play for my vote on Tuesday by delivering their candidate’s leaflet. As they have finally made the effort I’ll be reasonable (yes, yes, I know) and take a look at what they have to say.

Like the watermelon he lives in the ward, which is a good start. He has also been a councillor before but I do not know which borough and when. I do know from looking up last years’s result for this ward that he stood then and came fourth.

He makes a point of saying that he sends his kids to the local schools but doesn’t say which ones. Given that the borough contains 4 of the grammar schools (all single sex, split evenly) left in the country as well as a well respected Catholic secondary school (plus plenty of dross) I wonder which schools he is referring to? This supposed attempt at being one of the locals is followed up by a swift dig at the Liberal Democrats over tuition fees. He’s obviously forgotten which party introduced university fees to start with…

Anyway, enough of the national issues, let’s see what he has to say about local stuff. The leaflet makes a great play about local services, such as the police, libraries and children’s centres being under threat. Well obviously no-one wants to see services like these cut, do they? So what claims is he making as to the likelihood of reductions in the aforementioned services?

  • Police: Allegedly up to 400 Police Officers are under threat, which is obvious electioneering as I doubt the borough has even seen 400 coppers within its boundaries, even at airshow time. Whether the 400 figure is accurate on a county wide basis, or indeed if all 400 job cuts will be from the ranks of the police, rather than support staff, I do not know.
  • Libraries: He is focused particularly on the one in the ward, which is only fair, saying he will oppose plans to reduce opening hours or close it completely. Seeing as how I never done anything but walk, cycle or drive past it I can’t comment on how well used it is but having checked it is second only to the one in the main town in the number of hours it is open for on a weekly basis so will having a few hours trimmed from this make a massive difference? He would also like it to become the focus for local activity within the ward, which rather implies that it isn’t currently and, assuming that market forces are at work here, seemingly doesn’t need to be.
  • Children’s centres: This was apparently a throw away remark as no further reference is made. Scaremongering? Looks like as ‘Children and Learning’ spending would appear to be going up according to a quick glance at the budget.

His priorities, aside from the local library are this familiar restrains of dog fouling and littering – both banes of any urban environment it seems. And here it seems I am in agreement with him and he wants action against those who are guilty of such annoying behaviour. Score one for a socialist, who’d have thought it?

The back of the has, as I suppose is mandatory, something from high command. In this case that something is a picture of Millipede Jr. trying to smile (he shouldn’t) and a message telling us we should vote Labour to oppose the cuts as they will mean that our children will be back in the workhouse. Ah no, sorry, he just said that they will mean only the privileged few children will be able to get good jobs and opportunities. That’s right, he is opposing the cuts for the sake of the children. He is already on that fallback line? Not good for someone who has only been leader for 6 and a bit months.

Local Election 2011 Round-Up: Green Party

Two of the rules I try to live by with elections are:

1) If you don’t bother even trying to obtain my vote – either by canvasing or something as simple as sticking a leaflet through my door – then I don’t see why I should bother voting for you, and
2) I would prefer it if those seeking election lived within the area that they wished to represent.

I realise that the latter is perhaps easier for a constituency MP wannabes than local councillor wannabes but it would be nice to see an effort being made.

On that basis I look at the list of individuals who are standing for election in my council ward on May 5th with some dismay. The five individuals standing consist of a representative from the three big parties (Conservative, Labour, Liberal Democrats) as well as one from the Green’s and an Independent. Of these, two (the Conservative – who lives about as far away from the ward as it is possible to get given that this ward is fairly central within the borough – and the Independent – the current councillor) fall foul of my second wish, whilst only the Green party candidate has so far (with seven days to go) fulfilled the first.

If I am to stick to my principles then it currently looks like the watermelon or bust. On that basis I’d better see what the Green has to say for himself in his election leaflet* on the off chance it appeals.

The first signs are not good. His slogan is “Fighting for a fair deal for people and the planet” but I have no context to go with the term ‘fair’. Does he mean the dictionary definition or that spouted by the ‘progressives’? Perhaps the rest of this leaflet will make it clear.

Next we get his biographical details, confirming he does live in the ward (nice to know), works as a lecturer (uh oh) and keeps himself occupied with an allotment, being a home brewer (this alone might make me like him) and write (a google search turns up one book on the aforementioned home brewing). The search also turns up an appearance (length unknown) in the Oz Clarke and Hugh Dennis program ‘Oz and Hugh Raise the Bar’. Add to this the fact that he is a trade union activist who manages to ‘regularly organise campaigns and represent people at work’ and he certainly comes across as a busy little beaver. I wonder how he manages to find the time to actually lecture students. Or is he a full time unionista paid for by the taxpayer? And if that isn’t enough he has also managed to produce three sprogs – something which doesn’t appear to fit with the greenie over-population agenda.

So, enough about him. What about what he stands for? Sorry, no, he seems to have forgotten to put that on this leaflet. Instead the next bullet point tells me that he believes

… that local people need a strong voice in the face of job and service cuts locally, to protect our environment as well as bringing back accountability to local politics.

Now, admittedly, I haven’t been keeping my ears to the ground regarding local politics (Julia manages this far better than I) but as a non-user of almost any service provided I don’t recall any wailing and gnashing of teeth about any ‘cruel’ cuts made by the council so I think I can assume that the locals generally think nothing too onerous is happening. As for the environment, the ward is a concrete jungle so there isn’t a lot to protect as far as I see it and as regards accountability it sounds like a nice idea but I’ll believe that when I see it. Without lots of power being returned from the centre in Westminster and until councillors become directly responsible for services rather than being stuck at arms length behind the local chief executive and their staff that statement is a pipe dream.

On the reverse of the leaflet he then proceeds to parrot what I can only assume is the official Green party line as it talks about an ‘alternative to this governments (sic) cuts agenda’, ‘bring[ing] new thinking and fresh ideas’ via their MP and MEPs and a ‘sense of urgency about the truly important things in life’ without any clarifying of these airy sounding phrases. I’m also told the position of the Green Party regarding the AV referendum.

All in all I don’t think that I’ll be bringing myself to put a cross next to this candidate next Thursday. Looks like it’ll be a spoilt ballot paper at this rate.

* Assuming you can call the postcard sized piece of ‘greencoat paper using vegetable inks’ a leaflet?